Are Scholarships, Grants, and Awards from Private Foundations Taxable to Individual Recipients?
The taxability of scholarships, grants, and awards from private foundations largely depends on their intended use and compliance with IRS rules. While scholarships for qualified educational expenses are often tax-free, funds for other purposes, such as non-accredited studies, personal development, or living costs, may be taxable. Proper documentation and adherence to guidelines are critical to ensuring compliance and minimizing tax liabilities for both foundations and recipients.
Scholarships for Study at Qualified Educational Institutions
Scholarships are one of the most common ways private foundations support education, but their tax treatment hinges on specific criteria. For a scholarship to be tax-free, the recipient must be enrolled as a degree candidate at a qualified educational institution, and the funds must be used for qualified educational expenses (IRC §117). These expenses must be required for enrollment or attendance. Optional expenses, even if education-related, are generally taxable. Qualified educational expenses include tuition, mandatory fees, and the cost of books, supplies, and equipment directly related to the program of study. (IRS Pub. 970)
However, scholarships used for non-qualified expenses, such as room and board, travel, or general living stipends, are fully taxable. For example, if a student receives a fellowship that covers both tuition and a monthly stipend for living expenses, the tuition portion is tax-free, but the stipend is taxable and must be reported as income when filing a tax return.
To illustrate, consider a $15,000 scholarship awarded to a student. If $12,000 is spent on tuition and $3,000 on on-campus housing, the $12,000 used for tuition is tax-free, while the $3,000 for housing is considered taxable income. Similarly, if part of the scholarship is used to purchase a laptop required for coursework, that amount is tax-free. On the other hand, funds spent on a general-purpose tablet for personal use would be taxable.
An important factor in determining the tax status of a scholarship is whether the institution meets the IRS’s definition of a qualified educational institution. These institutions must be eligible for Title IV federal student aid programs and accredited by a recognized body. While most colleges and universities in the United States meet these criteria, certain vocational schools and some foreign institutions may also qualify. For instance, attending an accredited university in Canada could still allow a student to benefit from tax-free scholarships, provided the institution meets the U.S. Department of Education's standards.
Grants or Awards for Travel or Study at Non-Qualified Educational Institutions
Grants or awards from private foundations that support travel or study outside of qualified educational institutions are generally taxable (IRS Pub. 525). While these funds can provide invaluable opportunities for learning and professional development, the IRS imposes strict guidelines for tax-free scholarships and grants. When the funds fall outside these boundaries, recipients are typically required to report the grant as taxable income.
For example, a grant awarded to support independent research on ancient pottery techniques in Greece would be fully taxable if the research is not tied to enrollment at a qualified educational institution. Similarly, funding provided for attendance at a non-accredited workshop, such as a creative writing retreat, is also considered taxable. Although these activities may significantly enhance the recipient’s expertise or advance their career, they do not meet the IRS’s criteria for tax-free treatment. Grants made for personal development, such as leadership training, mindfulness retreats, or self-improvement workshops, are also generally taxable, even if the recipient benefits professionally or personally from the experience. In contrast however, if a grant is applied to tuition for a semester-long program at an accredited institution, it should qualify for tax-free treatment if used for tuition or other qualified expenses, such as books or required materials.
Grants for travel are generally taxable unless they are directly tied to a qualified educational program. For example, airfare provided by a foundation for a scientist to attend a non-accredited international conference in France is taxable, even if the conference offers valuable networking or professional development opportunities. Travel grants for non-educational purposes, such as attending workshops, conferences, or retreats that are not affiliated with accredited institutions, must also be reported as taxable income.
However, as an exception, travel expenses for programs directly tied to qualified educational activities at accredited institutions are generally non-taxable. If the grant supports enrollment in a formal program that meets IRS criteria, such as a study abroad program organized by a qualified educational institution, the related travel expenses may be considered non-taxable. The key factor is that the program must be part of the institution's curriculum, and the grant must cover qualified educational expenses like tuition, required fees, or essential travel related to the program.
Emergency Assistance and Hardship Grants
Emergency assistance and hardship grants are a vital way for private foundations to support individuals facing unexpected financial crises. These grants often address basic needs during emergencies, such as housing, food, medical care, or disaster recovery. To ensure compliance with IRS guidelines, such grants must meet specific criteria, including serving a "charitable class" and conducting an objective assessment of financial need.
For these grants to remain non-taxable, they must serve an immediate need and meet specific IRS criteria. A "charitable class" refers to a group that is large or indefinite enough to benefit the community as a whole rather than specific, pre-selected individuals. For example, aid provided to victims of a natural disaster in a region would qualify, while grants limited to a small, fixed group may not. The foundation must conduct an objective assessment of the recipient’s financial situation and document the recipient’s need for assistance. Short-term emergency aid, such as food and blankets distributed after a disaster, may not require a detailed financial assessment, but long-term assistance, like housing payments, must be based on thorough documentation of financial need.
Documentation is critical to demonstrate the charitable purpose of grants. Foundations should record details such as the type and cost of assistance provided, the purpose of the aid, the criteria used for selecting recipients, and information about the recipients (e.g., name, address, and amount distributed). Maintaining these records protects foundations from IRS scrutiny and ensures compliance.
Emergency assistance grants are typically limited to addressing immediate needs following a disaster or emergency, such as food, shelter, and transportation (IRC §139). For instance, a family displaced by a hurricane receiving $5,000 for temporary housing and repairs would qualify as disaster relief, making the grant non-taxable (IRS Pub. 3833). Similarly, medical emergency grants may be used to cover life-threatening conditions and typically do not require financial eligibility criteria beyond verification of the medical need. Foundations are encouraged to cap these grants at reasonable amounts, such as $5,000, to demonstrate fiscal responsibility and avoid excessive distributions. It is important to note that the mention of $5,000 as an informal cap aligns with general best practices, though this figure is not a strict IRS guideline but rather a common industry practice.
Prizes or Awards for Achievements
Prizes or awards recognizing individual achievements, such as contributions to the arts, sciences, or other fields, are generally taxable to the recipient (IRC §74). These awards, which can be awarded by private foundations (although some award programs may require explicit IRS approval), serve to honor significant accomplishments and provide financial support for continued work. Unless specific conditions are met, the recipient must report the prize as taxable income.
A notable example is the MacArthur Fellows Program, commonly known as the "Genius Grant." Administered by the MacArthur Foundation, this prestigious award is given annually to individuals who demonstrate exceptional creativity and potential for future contributions in their fields. Recipients are selected through a confidential nomination process and are awarded $800,000, paid in installments over five years. The funds are unrestricted, allowing recipients to use them as they see fit, whether to advance their work or for personal purposes. Because recipients retain the funds, the award is taxable under federal income tax laws.
While awards like the MacArthur Fellowship provide a unique opportunity for recipients to focus on their work, there are instances where such prizes can be structured to avoid taxation but they amount to the recipient giving the funds away. To qualify as non-taxable, three key criteria must be met:
1. The funds must be directed to a qualifying tax-exempt charity or governmental entity without the recipient taking possession of the money.
2. The recipient must be chosen without taking any action to enter the contest, competition, or selection process.
3. The award must not require the recipient to perform future services.
So if a foundation awards a prize to an individual but allows the funds to be redirected to a charitable organization, the recipient can avoid tax liability, provided they do not retain the funds or benefit personally.
Grants to Support Religious Mission Trips
Private foundations sometimes provide grants to support religious mission trips, which can vary in purpose, ranging from humanitarian aid to religious outreach. The tax treatment of such grants depends on how they are structured and to whom they are awarded.
Grants made directly to individuals to fund participation in a mission trip are generally considered taxable income, as they are typically treated as travel grants. For example, if a foundation provides a grant to an individual to cover travel expenses for a mission trip to build homes in a developing country, the funds are taxable to the recipient. This aligns with IRS rules that treat such travel grants as personal income unless they meet specific exceptions.
However, if the private foundation operates the mission trip directly, the situation changes. In this case, the foundation might cover expenses like airfare and lodging directly by using its own resources, such as paying the airline and hotels with the foundation’s credit card. Since these expenses are part of the foundation’s direct operating program, they are not treated as grants to individuals and therefore are not taxable to participants. Similarly, the foundation could reimburse minor expenses incurred by participants, such as purchasing materials necessary for the mission, without creating taxable income for those individuals.
Another way to avoid taxability for mission trip grants is to structure the funding through a tax-exempt organization, such as a church. For instance, a foundation could award a grant to a church to fund a group mission trip, with the church managing the expenses for airfare, accommodations, and supplies. In this case, the grant is treated as a direct grant to the church rather than to individuals, and the participants do not incur taxable income.
The key distinction lies in whether the funds are granted directly to individuals or managed through a tax-exempt organization or as part of the foundation’s direct operating programs. Proper structuring and documentation can ensure compliance and avoid unnecessary tax burdens for the participants.
Tax Reporting for Payments by Private Foundations: Form 1099-NEC and 1099-MISC
Private foundations must carefully evaluate their payments to individuals to determine whether IRS reporting is required. Payments may need to be reported using Form 1099-NEC or Form 1099-MISC, depending on their nature. Properly distinguishing between these forms ensures compliance and helps recipients accurately report their income.
Form 1099-NEC (Nonemployee Compensation)
Form 1099-NEC is required for payments of $600 or more made to individuals for services rendered, such as payments to independent contractors or other non-employees. However, this form is generally not applicable to grants or awards provided by private foundations, which are rarely payments for services.
However, if a private foundation hires an independent contractor to coordinate a mission trip or manage an event, and the contractor earns $600 or more, the foundation must issue Form 1099-NEC. Similarly, payments to professionals, such as writers or consultants conducting program evaluations, must also be reported on this form.
In the context of grants to individuals, private foundations typically do not issue Form 1099-NEC because grants are not compensation for services. However, if a foundation engages an individual for compensatory services, issuing this form is necessary to ensure compliance and proper income reporting by the recipient.
Form 1099-MISC (Miscellaneous Income)
Form 1099-MISC is used to report taxable payments not tied to services, such as prizes, awards, and certain grants. Payments of $600 or more are generally reportable unless they qualify as tax-exempt under IRS rules.
For example, if a foundation awards a $2,000 grant to an individual to attend a non-accredited creative writing workshop, the payment must be reported on Form 1099-MISC because it does not meet the criteria for tax-free educational assistance. Similarly, travel grants provided for non-educational purposes—such as airfare to attend a professional conference unrelated to a qualified educational program—are also reportable.
Direct grants to individuals for mission trips are another example. If a foundation provides $2,000 directly to a participant for mission-related travel and lodging, the payment is taxable unless it is structured as a program expense or issued through a tax-exempt organization like a church.
However, payments exclusively for qualified educational expenses—such as tuition and books—or for qualified disaster relief, like emergency housing and medical care, are tax-free and do not require reporting on Form 1099-MISC. Even when a Form 1099 is not required, maintaining detailed records of the payment’s purpose, eligibility criteria, and related documentation is essential. Proper classification ensures compliance and minimizes the risk of IRS scrutiny.
Conclusion
The tax implications of scholarships, grants, and awards from private foundations are complex, hinging on their purpose and structure. Foundations must carefully adhere to IRS guidelines to prevent unintended tax consequences for both themselves and recipients. Likewise, recipients should seek guidance from tax professionals to address their unique circumstances. By collaborating and prioritizing compliance, foundations and recipients can ensure these impactful gifts achieve their intended goals while maintaining regulatory requirements.
Seeking expert guidance? We're here to help!
At CPA KPA, we're passionate about magnifying the positive impact of foundations. Feel free to reach out to us anytime at 888-402-1780 for a complimentary and obligation-free conversation. You can also conveniently submit your questions and inquiries through our contact page. Let's connect today and explore how we can help your foundation have a lasting and meaningful impact!
