How do you start a private foundation?
Starting a private foundation is a complex process that requires careful planning, detailed paperwork, and a thorough understanding of legal and regulatory requirements. Private foundations can be structured as either nonprofit corporations or legal trusts, with nonprofit corporations being the more commonly chosen option. Either way, establishing a private foundation involves navigating a variety of steps and adhering to specific rules designed to ensure compliance with both federal and state laws.
The process begins with defining the foundation's charitable purpose and understanding the structural options available. Nonprofit corporations and trusts are governed by different legal statutes, each with unique implications for how the foundation is managed and operated. Regardless of the structure chosen, creating a private foundation is rarely a do-it-yourself endeavor—professional expertise is strongly recommended to help navigate the intricacies of formation, compliance, and ongoing management.
This article outlines the essential steps in establishing a private foundation, from the initial planning stages to the operational and reporting requirements necessary to maintain compliance and fulfill the foundation’s mission.
Define the Charitable Purpose
To qualify as a tax-exempt organization, a foundation must align its purpose with those outlined in Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. This means its purpose should fall into one of the following categories: charitable, religious, educational, scientific, literary, testing for public safety, fostering national or international amateur sports competition, or preventing cruelty to children or animals. Foundations have the flexibility to define their mission broadly, allowing for a wide range of activities, or narrowly, focusing on specific causes or initiatives.
Check Name Availability
One of the first steps in establishing a foundation is to verify that your chosen name is available in your state. This can typically be done through the Secretary of State's office. In most cases, having a name similar to an existing foundation is allowed. For example, if "Kirk Foundation" is already registered in your state, you would likely still be able to register "James T. Kirk Foundation." While this step is generally not required for foundations organized as trusts, it is still a good practice. Trusts can easily distinguish their names by including unique identifiers, such as a date stamp.
Legal Formation
Forming a private foundation involves establishing its legal structure, which typically requires either incorporation as a nonprofit corporation or the creation of a trust. For foundations organized as nonprofit corporations, this process involves drafting and filing articles of incorporation, the foundational document that formally establishes the organization within its home state. These articles must comply with state-specific legal requirements and include key provisions, such as the foundation's name, purpose, and governance structure. The date of incorporation is significant, as it officially marks the "birthdate" of the foundation and establishes its legal existence.
In contrast, foundations organized as trusts require the creation of a trust document, often called a deed of trust or trust agreement. This document serves a similar purpose, outlining the foundation's mission, governance, and operational guidelines. While trusts are less commonly used than nonprofit corporations, they may be appropriate for certain situations.
Apply for a Federal Employment Identification Number (EIN)
Every private foundation must obtain a Federal Employer Identification Number (EIN), which serves as its unique identifier, much like a Social Security number for an individual. This number is essential for various administrative purposes, including opening bank accounts, filing tax returns, and complying with IRS requirements.
The process of applying for an EIN is straightforward and can be completed online through the IRS website. The application typically takes only a few minutes, and the EIN is issued immediately upon approval. It's important to understand that obtaining an EIN is mandatory for all foundations, even if they do not plan to hire employees.
Draft Bylaws
For private foundations organized as nonprofit corporations, drafting bylaws is a critical step in defining how the organization will operate on a day-to-day basis. Bylaws serve as the guiding rules for governance and typically outline key elements such as meeting procedures, the roles and responsibilities of officers and directors, terms of service, voting protocols, and processes for handling conflicts of interest. These bylaws must comply with both IRS regulations and the specific legal requirements of the state in which the foundation is incorporated.
Bylaws are more than just a formality; they provide the framework for decision-making, help maintain consistency in operations, and ensure that the foundation remains aligned with its mission. Well-drafted bylaws can also protect the foundation by minimizing the risk of disputes among board members or officers. As such, engaging legal or nonprofit professionals to craft bylaws that are both comprehensive and compliant is highly recommended.
For foundations established as trusts, bylaws are not applicable. Instead, these organizations are governed by a trust agreement or deed of trust. This document functions similarly to bylaws but is tailored to the unique legal structure of a trust. It outlines the trustee’s duties, the foundation’s purpose, the management of assets, and provisions for succession or amendments. The trust agreement is a binding legal document that ensures the foundation operates according to the donor's wishes and complies with applicable laws.
Draft Conflict-of-Interest Policy
The IRS strongly recommends adopting a conflict-of-interest policy—nearly to the point of making it a requirement—as a cornerstone of good governance for private foundations. While not legally mandated, the IRS application for 501(c)(3) status explicitly inquires about the existence of such a policy. Failing to have one can attract scrutiny during the review process and may delay or even jeopardize the approval of the foundation’s tax-exempt status.
A well-crafted conflict-of-interest policy ensures that board members, officers, and key employees prioritize the organization’s interests over personal gain. It protects the foundation’s integrity by requiring the disclosure of potential conflicts, establishing clear steps for managing them, and often mandates annual statements to reaffirm compliance.
Beyond fostering ethical decision-making, this policy plays a vital role in maintaining public trust and ensuring the organization’s actions remain aligned with its charitable mission. To further enhance transparency and accountability, many organizations also include provisions for documenting how conflicts are identified and resolved.
Draft Grantmaking Policy
A grantmaking policy establishes the framework for how a private foundation awards funds, ensuring alignment with its charitable mission and compliance with legal requirements. An essential decision is whether the foundation will accept unsolicited grant requests or exclusively select grantees based on its own criteria and proactive selection process. This decision significantly influences the foundation's operational focus and outreach and should be clearly articulated in the policy.
The policy should also define eligibility criteria for grants, detail the application and review process (if unsolicited requests are accepted), and establish clear guidelines for monitoring how grant funds are used. For restricted grants tied to specific projects or purposes, it is not uncommon to require reporting from grantees to ensure compliance and accountability. However, for unrestricted general-purpose operating grants, reporting requirements are much less frequent unless the grants are exceptionally large. The policy should balance the need for oversight with the administrative burden on grantees, setting expectations accordingly.
To ensure integrity, it should address potential conflicts of interest and include measures to prevent grants that provide personal benefit to board members or officers. Additionally, the policy must specify prohibited uses of funds, such as lobbying, political activities, or funding activities that generate excessive private benefit or inurement.
Application for 501(c)(3) status
Obtaining 501(c)(3) status is a crucial step for private foundations seeking recognition as tax-exempt organizations. This process involves completing and submitting Form 1023 to the IRS, along with the required user fee. Applications must be submitted online through the IRS system. Once submitted, Form 1023 undergoes a detailed review by an IRS agent, a process that typically takes six to twelve months, with approvals rarely granted in under six months. During this time, the IRS often requests additional information or clarifications from the applicant organization.
To streamline the approval process, it is critical to ensure that the foundation’s organizing documents include the following key elements:
1. Charitable Purpose Clause: Clearly articulate the foundation's charitable activities, ensuring they align with the IRS-defined purposes under Section 501(c)(3).
2. Limitation on Lobbying Clause: State that the foundation will not engage in lobbying activities or political campaigns, such as endorsing specific political candidates.
3. Private Inurement Clause: Confirm that the foundation’s income and assets will be used exclusively for charitable purposes and will not benefit any private individual.
4. Charitable Dissolution Clause: Specify that, upon dissolution, the foundation's remaining assets will be distributed to another qualified 501(c)(3) organization.
Once the IRS approves the application, the organization receives a determination letter officially recognizing its tax-exempt status as a private foundation under Section 501(c)(3). This letter is a vital document that must be securely stored along with a copy of the Form 1023 application. It serves as proof of tax-exempt status and may be requested by donors, grantmakers, or the public to verify the foundation's legitimacy.
State Tax Exemption
After obtaining 501(c)(3) status from the IRS, private foundations may need to take additional steps to secure state-level tax-exempt recognition. Many states, such as California, require a separate filing with the state’s department of revenue or equivalent agency. These filings typically confirm the foundation's federal tax-exempt status and may involve submitting organizational documents, financial information, and the IRS determination letter.
The requirements and processes for obtaining state tax exemption vary significantly from one state to another. Some states automatically grant tax-exempt status to organizations recognized by the IRS, while others require a formal application or registration process. Additionally, the types of tax exemptions available—such as income, sales, or property tax exemptions—depend on state-specific rules and the foundation’s planned activities. Foundations should research the requirements of the state where they are operating or consult with legal or tax professionals familiar with local laws.
State Fundraising Registration
If a private foundation plans to solicit contributions or donations from the public, most states require the organization to register with the appropriate regulatory body, such as the state attorney general or a similar agency overseeing charitable organizations. This registration is intended to promote transparency and accountability in fundraising activities, ensuring compliance with state laws designed to protect donors and the public.
However, if a foundation primarily relies on substantial contributions from family members or a small group of close affiliates, such registration may not be necessary in many states. These exceptions often depend on the specific fundraising practices and the foundation's donor base.
It’s important to understand that state fundraising registration requirements vary widely. Some states require annual renewals and additional disclosures, while others have less stringent rules. Non-compliance with these regulations can result in penalties or limitations on fundraising activities, so foundations should carefully review the laws in the states where they intend to operate. Foundations planning to solicit funds across multiple states should consider using professional services or legal counsel to manage the complexities of multi-state compliance.
Ongoing requirements
The ongoing requirements for managing private foundations are intricate, with significant penalties for non-compliance. For most private foundations, the IRS mandates an annual distribution of approximately 5% of the foundation's non-charitable assets toward its charitable mission. This "mandatory distribution requirement" is designed to ensure that the foundation actively furthers its exempt purpose, rather than passively holding assets. Failing to meet this requirement can result in substantial excise taxes and penalties.
Foundations are also required to report annually to the IRS by filing Form 990-PF. This form is not just a regulatory filing—it is a public document that provides a detailed look into the foundation’s finances, governance, grantmaking activities, and compliance with legal requirements. By making this information publicly accessible, Form 990-PF plays a critical role in promoting transparency and accountability in the nonprofit sector. Potential donors, grant recipients, and regulatory bodies can use this document to evaluate the foundation’s practices and impact.
In addition to these obligations, nearly all private foundations are required to pay an excise tax on their net investment income. Currently set at 1.39%, this tax applies to income derived from interest, dividends, capital gains, and similar sources. The purpose of this tax is to ensure that private foundations contribute modestly to the federal tax system while retaining their tax-exempt status.
Finally, compliance with state-specific regulations is vital. These requirements can include additional state filings, registration for fundraising activities, and adherence to laws governing charitable organizations in the state of operation. For example, some states may require periodic updates to maintain charitable registration, while others impose specific rules regarding financial disclosures or the use of solicited funds.
Given the complexity of these federal and state requirements, foundations are strongly advised to seek professional assistance. Skilled legal or tax advisors can help navigate the intricate landscape of nonprofit management, ensuring that the foundation remains compliant and focused on fulfilling its mission.
Seeking expert guidance? We're here to help!
At CPA KPA, we're passionate about magnifying the positive impact of private foundations. Feel free to reach out to us anytime at 888-402-1780 for a complimentary and obligation-free conversation. You can also conveniently submit your questions and inquiries through our contact page. Let's connect today and explore how we can help your foundation have a lasting and meaningful impact!