What are the fiduciary duties of private foundation board members and trustees?
Private foundation board members, along with trustees, hold a pivotal role in steering the organization toward fulfilling its ethical and legal obligations. Fiduciary duties are not merely ethical guidelines; they are legal obligations grounded in the law. For private foundations, which enjoy tax-exempt status and operate under public scrutiny, these duties are particularly critical. Missteps can jeopardize the foundation’s status, expose it to penalties, and damage its reputation. As fiduciaries, board members and trustees are entrusted with the weighty responsibility of acting in the best interests of the foundation.
In the following sections, we will delve into the three fundamental fiduciary duties that board members owe to the foundation: the duty of care, loyalty, and obedience.
Duty of Care
The duty of care requires board members to act with diligence, prudence, and attention, reflecting the level of care that a reasonably prudent person would exercise in similar circumstances. This involves actively participating in the foundation’s governance, staying informed about its operations, and making thoughtful, well-informed decisions. To meet this duty effectively, board members should focus on the following key responsibilities:
• Engaged Participation: Actively engage in overseeing the foundation's day-to-day operations. This includes attending board meetings, reviewing meeting minutes, and scrutinizing reports. Effective board members remain vigilant, seeking additional information when necessary to make informed decisions and promptly addressing irregularities.
• Meeting Minutes: Ensure that accurate meeting minutes are taken at every board meeting. These minutes serve as vital records summarizing discussions, decisions, and official actions. They offer a historical perspective and provide a basis for accountability.
• Books and Records: Regularly review the foundation's financial records, including accounting documents, tax returns, and grant records. For larger foundations, an independent audit by a CPA firm is prudent to maintain financial transparency and integrity. Audits not only verify financial accuracy but also provide assurance to donors and regulators.
• Committees: Supervise and oversee all committees within the foundation, regularly assessing their progress and contributions to the foundation's mission.
• Safekeeping of Property: Board members must act judiciously in safeguarding and managing foundation assets, ensuring they are used exclusively for charitable purposes and not for the benefit of insiders.
• Prudent Investment Strategies: Board members should oversee and ensure the implementation of prudent investment strategies for the foundation's assets. This includes diversifying investments, minimizing risk, and consistently monitoring the performance of investment portfolios to align with the foundation's long-term financial sustainability and charitable goals. The Uniform Prudent Management of Institutional Funds Act (UPMIFA), adopted in many states, provides a legal framework for such investment decisions.
• Whistleblower Provisions: Establish mechanisms to address allegations of mismanagement or wrongdoing promptly. Ensure that the foundation does not retaliate against employee whistleblowers, as they are protected under the law.
Duty of Loyalty
The duty of loyalty requires board members to prioritize the foundation’s interests above their own personal or professional gain. This obligation ensures that all decisions are made solely to benefit the foundation, free from conflicts of interest or improper influence. Upholding this duty strengthens the foundation’s integrity and fosters trust among stakeholders. To meet this standard, board members should focus on the following actions:
• Ethical Decision-Making: Board members should operate with the utmost integrity, avoiding any actions that could result in personal or family gain at the foundation's expense. Transparent and ethical conduct is non-negotiable.
• Conflict-of-Interest Policies: The implementation and strict adherence to conflict-of-interest policies are paramount. These policies outline procedures for identifying, disclosing, and managing conflicts of interest, safeguarding the foundation's integrity. For example, a board member who also serves on the board of another nonprofit applying for a grant from the foundation must disclose this affiliation and recuse themselves from discussions or votes related to the grant. This ensures transparency and prevents the perception of favoritism or impropriety.
Duty of Obedience
The duty of obedience obligates board members to ensure the foundation remains faithful to its mission while complying with all applicable laws and regulations. This includes respecting the foundation’s governing documents, adhering to its stated charitable purposes, and avoiding activities that could jeopardize its tax-exempt status. By embracing this responsibility, board members uphold the foundation’s purpose and public trust. Key actions to fulfill this duty include:
• Familiarize Themselves with Governing Documents: Board members should intimately understand and respect the foundation's governing documents, such as articles of incorporation and bylaws, as they provide the legal framework for the organization.
• Legal Compliance: Board members must remain vigilant in their commitment to upholding federal and state laws that pertain to foundation operations. This includes compliance with the Internal Revenue Code (IRC), particularly provisions like IRC §4941, which prohibits self-dealing. Adherence to employment regulations, tax filings, and grant reporting requirements is equally critical.
• Seek Professional Counsel: When necessary, seeking professional advice from attorneys, accountants, and other experts ensures adherence to legal compliance, sound financial management, and governance best practices.
Consequences of Breach
Failing to meet fiduciary responsibilities can have serious consequences, including personal liability for board members and trustees, excise taxes imposed by the IRS, and reputational damage to the foundation. For instance, violations of self-dealing rules under IRC §4941 can result in significant financial penalties.
Conclusion
Private foundation board members wield immense influence over their organization's success and integrity. By embracing their fiduciary duties of care, loyalty, and obedience, board members can safeguard the foundation's mission, uphold legal requirements, and earn the trust of stakeholders. Proactive governance practices, including ongoing education and seeking expert advice, further strengthen their ability to fulfill these vital responsibilities. In doing so, they ensure the foundation thrives while maintaining the trust of donors, beneficiaries, and regulators.
Seeking expert guidance? We're here to help!
At CPA KPA, we're passionate about magnifying the positive impact of private foundations. Feel free to reach out to us anytime at 888-402-1780 for a complimentary and obligation-free conversation. You can also conveniently submit your questions and inquiries through our contact page. Let's connect today and explore how we can help your foundation have a lasting and meaningful impact!